Current:Home > News'Serial' case keeps going: An undo turns into a redo in Adnan Syed murder conviction-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
'Serial' case keeps going: An undo turns into a redo in Adnan Syed murder conviction
View Date:2024-12-23 16:58:26
The Maryland Supreme Court on Friday ruled that a key hearing that led to Adnan Syed's release must be redone, extending a decades-long legal battle chronicled in the hit podcast "Serial."
The court agreed with a Maryland Appellate Court, which ruled the family of murder victim Hae Min Lee ‒ Syed's ex-girlfriend who was killed in 1999 ‒ had the right to appear in person at the hearing.
The latest ruling resets the case to before the hearing that ended with Syed walking free, giving Lee's family the chance to be present.
That means Syed's murder conviction will remain reinstated. Even so, Syed has remained out of prison amid the legal wrangling, and the Supreme Court said its ruling would not change the conditions of his release pending future proceedings, which could ultimately clear Syed's name.
"Though this latest ruling is a roadblock in the way of Adnan’s exoneration, we have faith that justice will prevail, and will work tirelessly to clear his name once and for all," Erica Suter, Syed's attorney and director of the Innocence Project at the University of Baltimore Law School, said in a statement shared with USA TODAY.
Syed was freed from prison almost two years ago after a Baltimore judge ruled that the state had improperly withheld exculpatory evidence from his defense team. Prosecutors later dropped his charges after they said DNA evidence suggested his innocence. Syed's case was popularized in 2014 with the podcast "Serial," prompting mass public advocacy campaigns on his behalf.
But in March of 2023, the Appellate Court of Maryland moved to reinstate his conviction, because it said the hearing that led to his release violated the rights of Lee's brother, Young Lee. The Appellate Court said Young Lee was only given less than one business day's notice of the hearing, and that he didn't have time to travel to Maryland from his home in California, so he could only appear virtually.
Suter argued the remote court appearance was sufficient, but on Friday Maryland's Supreme Court said he had the right to be there in person. Suter said the latest legal battle "was not about Adnan’s innocence," but was instead about the procedural issues that led his exoneration.
"In an effort to remedy what they perceived to be an injustice to Mr. Syed, the prosecutor and the circuit court worked an injustice against Mr. Lee by failing to treat him with dignity, respect, and sensitivity..." the Maryland Supreme Court wrote in its decision.
Suter said Syed's team recognizes the suffering of the Lee family, and that reinstating Syed's conviction does not ease that suffering while putting a "tremendous toll" on Syed and his family.
"After spending 23 years in prison for a crime he did not commit, Adnan is once again fighting for his freedom," Suter said.
The Baltimore City State's Attorney's office is reviewing the court's decision, spokesperson Emily Witty told USA TODAY.
veryGood! (5672)
Related
- Catholic bishops urged to boldly share church teachings — even unpopular ones
- Inside Brian Austin Green's Life as a Father of 5
- IDF reservist offers harrowing description of slaughters and massacres of Israeli civilians
- Nice player Atal investigated for ‘defending terrorism’ after reposting antisemitic message
- High-scoring night in NBA: Giannis Antetokounmpo explodes for 59, Victor Wembanyama for 50
- Medicare shoppers often face a barrage of unsolicited calls and aggressive ads
- Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce's NYC Takeover Continues With Stylish Dinner Date
- Sports, internet bets near-record levels in New Jersey, but 5 of 9 casinos trail pre-pandemic levels
- Olympic Skier Lindsey Vonn Coming Out of Retirement at 40
- How AI is speeding up scientific discoveries
Ranking
- Inside Dream Kardashian's Sporty 8th Birthday Party
- Italy approves 24 billion-euro budget that aims to boost household spending and births
- Medicare shoppers often face a barrage of unsolicited calls and aggressive ads
- AP PHOTOS: Scenes of pain and grief on war’s 10th day
- Brianna LaPaglia Addresses Zach Bryan's Deafening Silence After Emotional Abuse Allegations
- Biden speaks with families of Americans missing in Israel, possibly among hostages held by Hamas
- Women’s voices being heard at Vatican’s big meeting on church’s future, nun says
- Venice mayor orders halt to buses operated by company following second crash that injured 15
Recommendation
-
NFL playoff picture Week 10: Lions stay out in front of loaded NFC field
-
Slavery reparations in Amherst Massachusetts could include funding for youth programs and housing
-
UAW Strikes: How does autoworker union pay compare to other hourly jobs?
-
What is saffron? A beneficial, tasty, and pricey spice
-
Disney Store's Black Friday Sale Just Started: Save an Extra 20% When You Shop Early
-
Greece’s ruling conservatives suffer setbacks in regional, municipal elections
-
DeSantis says US shouldn’t take in Palestinian refugees from Gaza because they’re ‘all antisemitic’
-
As House goes into second weekend without new speaker, moderate House Democrats propose expanding temporary speaker's powers